Strategy

How to Choose a Local SEO Agency: 12 Questions to Ask

The questions that separate agencies that do local SEO from agencies that sell it, what good answers sound like, and the red flags.

By the Maps SEO teamPublished 17 November 2026

Most local SEO is sold, not done. The pitch decks look the same, the price lists look the same, and the difference between an agency that will put you in the local pack and one that will send you a PDF every month is invisible until three months in. These twelve questions surface it in the first conversation. We answer them for ourselves at the end, because you should ask us too.

1. "Show me the local pack for my main search from three places in my area."

An agency that does local SEO will do this on the call, or already has before it. One that cannot explain why the pack differs from place to place does not understand the thing it is selling.

2. "What primary category would you set, and why?"

The answer should reference the categories the current pack members use. "We'll optimise your categories" is not an answer.

3. "How do you get reviews?"

The right answer describes a process: links, timing, staff, responses. Any mention of supplying reviews, review "campaigns" with numbers attached, or filtering unhappy customers ends the conversation. It is a Google policy breach and, since April 2025, a banned practice under UK consumer law.

4. "How do you report rankings?"

Grid tracking — a map of positions across the area — is the honest method. A single rank number per keyword is misleading for local. A "visibility score" from a tool is meaningless.

5. "Which of my Google account's numbers will you report?"

Calls, direction requests, website clicks and discovery searches from the Business Profile Performance page. If the report will not include numbers you can verify yourself, the report is marketing.

6. "Who owns the Business Profile and the directory logins?"

You do. Always. The agency gets manager access. Any other answer is a hostage situation waiting to happen.

7. "What will you do in the first 30 days?"

Specific: audit against the pack, category and services, NAP audit, landing page, review link. Vague: "onboarding and strategy".

8. "How many citations will you build, and where?"

The right answer is a short list of relevant UK and industry sources, with correction of wrong ones first. "500 citations" means automated submissions and future duplicates.

9. "What is the contract length?"

Rolling monthly is normal for specialists. Twelve-month minimums are common at agencies whose retention depends on the contract rather than the results.

10. "Who will actually do the work, and can I message them?"

An account manager who relays to an offshore team is a different product from a specialist you can WhatsApp. Neither is wrong, but the price should reflect it.

11. "What happens if my profile gets suspended?"

Suspensions happen. An agency that has handled them will describe the evidence pack and appeal process. One that has not will say it never happens to their clients.

12. "What can't you do?"

Guarantee a position. Move a business closer to the town centre. Beat a competitor with 400 reviews in a month. Rank a virtual office. An agency that has no answer to this question has not been doing it long.

Red flags, briefly

  • "Guaranteed page one" or "guaranteed #1"
  • Reviews included in the package
  • Reports that never mention your Business Profile Performance data
  • They want to own the profile
  • The audit is a free automated PDF from a tool, unread by a human
  • Twelve-month contract with a setup fee
  • Local SEO is a line item under "digital marketing" alongside logo design

Our answers

  1. Yes — that is the free check.
  2. Tested against the pack for your top five searches, in the audit.
  3. Process only. Never supplied, never gated, never incentivised.
  4. 7×7 grid, monthly, shared as an image.
  5. Calls, directions, website clicks, discovery searches, alongside the grid.
  6. You. We are a manager.
  7. Audit, category/services, NAP corrections, landing page, review link, grid baseline.
  8. Around thirty, hand-built, corrections first. The list is public.
  9. Rolling, 30 days' notice.
  10. The person doing the work, on WhatsApp.
  11. Evidence pack and appeal, from £199 stand-alone, included on plans.
  12. All of the above, plus: we don't run ads and we don't build websites.
Ask us the twelve on WhatsApp. If our answers do not hold up, you have a better shortlist either way.

Read next

WhatsApp

Want to know why you're not in the local pack?

Send us your business name and postcode on WhatsApp. We'll reply with the three things holding your Google Maps ranking back — no forms, no sales call.

Message us on WhatsApp